An Introduction to Earth Mysteries
PART FIVE
In Part Four we saw how an increasing number of authors were joining the ground swell of 'alternative science' throughout the post wars years with some now providing 'evidence' of alien visitations.
Alien Sunset
Robert Temple's book, The Sirius Mystery (1976), in which he proposed that the Dogon people of north-western Mali in Africa preserved an account of
extraterrestrial visitation from around 5,000 years ago, proved to be a best-seller and was followed by Zecharia Sitchin with The 12th Planet (1976) the first book in the Earth Chronicles series, suggesting that a superior race of beings once inhabited our world, arguing that these travellers from the stars arrived on earth and planted the genetic seed that would develop into mankind. Using Sumerian texts, which according to Sitchin tell of the leader, Enki, of the first group of astronauts from the 12th planet in our solar system (Nibiru), splashed down in the Persian Gulf and waded ashore dressed as Fishmen.Ten years earlier in 1966, Ivan Shklovski and Carl Sagan cited in their book Intelligent Life in the Universe the tales of Oannes - the name given by the Babylonian writer Berossus in the 3rd century BC to a mythical fishlike being who brought wisdom to the early Sumerians - as deserving closer scrutiny as a possible instance of paleo-contact due to its consistency and detail.
Although it persisted throughout the 1970’s, following critical analysis of von Däniken's theories and a onslaught of debunking by scholars, highlighting basis errors on the author’s part, (some referred to them as outright fraudulent claims), the Ancient Astronaut theory waned in popularity. The refutation was led by Clifford Wilson in Crash Go The Chariots (1972) and Ronald Story in books such as The Space Gods Revealed, (1976) subtitled “The Chariots of the Gods Turned into a Pumpkin” with a foreword by Carl Sagan, highlighted inaccuracies in von Daniken’s speculations and assumptions and even borrowings from other writers. Story followed this up with Guardians of the Universe? (1980) further demolishing von Daniken’s Ancient Astronaut theory and challenging the notions of Charroux, Jessop, Temple, et al, complete with an appendix by J Richard Greenwell taking a swipe at Flindt and Binder; “Tiptoeing beyond Darwin: An Examination of some Unconventional Theories on the origin of Man”. Edwin C. Krupp, director of the Griffith Observatory in Los Angeles since 1974, waded into the debate debunking von Daniken and the Sirius myth in Observatories of the Gods and Other Astronomical Fantasies, in the book In Search of Ancient Astronomers (1977).
The case for Ancient Astronauts was not helped when in 1978 the Sun Gods in Exile: Secrets of the Dzopa of Tibet by Karyl Robin- Evans, told the story of how the author travelled to the "mysterious land of the Dzopa" in 1947.
Robin-Evans claimed to have encountered a tribe of dwarvish people called the Dropas (or Dzopas) in the Baian-Kara-Ula region. They claimed they were descended from aliens who arrived on earth twelve thousand years ago when their spacecraft crashed in the area. An alleged expedition to the region in 1938 claimed to have unearthed evidence of the remains of people of a small stature and some stone curious discs, known as the Dropa Stones. Robin-Evans had written an account, it was claimed, so unbelievable yet true that he would not publish it. Following his death in 1974, the story was published in 1978, edited by a man under the name of David Agamon, (or Gamon, who some claimed to actually be Robin-Evans) who later confessed in 1995 that it had all been a hoax, originally written as fiction, reworking rumour and legend, as a satire on the alien intervention of the evolution of the human race that was in vogue at the time. Second hand copies of this book now sell for fantastic amounts of money, (£200 +) as it has acquired cult status, still being regarded by some as an authentic account of an actual Ancient Astronaut event.Unfortunately for von Daniken, who wrote of the of the Dropas Stones in his book Gods From Outer Space (1970), sequel to Chariots of the Gods, the claimed source of his story, apparently a conversation with Soviet writer Aleksandr Kazantsev in Moscow in 1968 - who according to von Daniken, told him that the discs themselves and accounts of their discovery is preserved in Chinese academic institutes - could not be verified. Gordon Creighton of the Flying Saucer Review, contacted a number of Chinese academics about the Dropa stones story, and none of them had even heard of the story. He then contacted Kazantsev to verify von Daniken’s account but surprisingly the response was that von Daniken had actually presented it to Kazantsev and he was indeed not the source.
Writing in 1979 in Broca's Brain, Sagan suggested that he and co-author Shklovski may possibly have been the inspiration behind the wave of Ancient Astronaut books during the 1970’s. Sagan had felt extraterrestrial visits in Earth’s distant past were certainly a possibility but totally unproven and the accounts of von Daniken and his ilk, were no more than unfounded speculation lacking any hard evidence, doing the theory more harm than good. There is little doubt that the fraudulent claims of some authors as sensationalistic attempts to cash in on the ground swell of interest in UFOs in the 1960 - 70’s did immense damage to the genuine possibility of prehistoric extra-terrestrial contact.Today the theory is only supported by what is generally considered as the ‘fringe’ minority but still it persists with books like The Chinese Roswell: Ufo Encounters in the Far East from Ancient Times to the Present (1995) by Hartwig Hausdorf in which the author in searching for the fabled, forbidden 1,000-foot White Pyramid of Xian, unearthed new facts about the mysterious Dropa stone discs of Bayan Kara Ula, which some believe tell the story of a forced alien landing 12,000 years ago, as we have seen above. Voices from Legendary Times (2005), by Ellen Lloyd, discusses the connection between lost civilizations, ancient cosmic catastrophes and extraterrestrial visitations in prehistory, however, Sitchin remains the present day champion of the theory, having recently released The Earth Chronicles Handbook (May 2009), a compendium of the seven books in the series, “a unique encyclopaedia of ancient civilizations and their space connections…..”
Whereas, most Unidentified Flying Objects can be explained, although not always convincingly, there persists a small percentage of UFO’s that remain unidentified, leaving open the possibility that these could be genuine visitations from a distant world. The public imagination would appear to be very receptive to the notion of visitations to our planet in the distant past and the possibility of mankind’s development being influenced by extra-terrestrials, despite the arguments against it presented by the debunkers and eminent scholars. Man’s origins are murky to say the least and it is not difficult to see that the orthodox account of mankind's origins is holed below the water line.
However, the fundamental problem of the Ancient Astronaut theory is that modern man in his technological age cannot accept that our so called 'primitive' ancestors could possibly have built these ancient astronomically aligned structures - like the pyramids of Giza for example, moving massive blocks of stone weighing hundreds of tons with such precision that in some cases you cannot fit a thin blade between these huge megalithic blocks - without the assistance of a higher civilisation.Why does Mankind need to be a child of the stars?
Part VI - When Worlds Collide
* * *





