Resolving the Enigma
Michael Dames
The mystery of Silbury would appear to be something that keeps author Michael Dames awake at night; in his latest book Sibury: Resolving the Enigma he returns yet again to the largest man-made mound in prehistoric Europe.
In his first book
The Silbury Treasure: The Great Goddess Rediscovered (1976) Michael Dames set out to interpret the meaning of Silbury Hill, the largest man-made prehistoric structure in Europe. Suggesting that the hill was constructed as a symbolic landscape effigy of the ancient Mother Goddess associated with fertility rituals marking out the course of the year, Dames proposed that Silbury was founded during the month of August, the festival of Lugnasadh, celebrating the first fruits of the harvest. Five hundred yards south of Silbury the source of the River Kennet rises on the hillside below the West Kennet Long Barrow which according to Dames was formerly called the “
Cunnit”, a name he connects to the fertility Goddess, for obvious reasons.
[1] He went on to propose that Silbury and the local landscape features formed a gigantic effigy of the pregnant Neolithic harvest goddess, delivering an annual birthing of “
first fruits”. However, he ultimately concluded that the monument remained a massive man-made enigma.

Dames investigated the harvest Goddess theme further in his second book
The Avebury Cycle (1977) exploring the landscape centred on Avebury, proposing a collective purpose of seasonal rituals for Silbury and its associated sites of
West Kennet Long Barrow, Avebury henge, The Sanctuary, and
Windmill Hill, from which the summit of Silbury Hill,
the Goddess, maintains visibility. Dames makes use of archaeology, ethnography and folklore to propose that these monuments were fundamental in the worship of the harvest Goddess, each representing different aspects of the annual fertility cycle corresponding to the agricultural year.
In The
Silbury Treasure, Dames included a short appendix
'Silbury in the Roman Period', a topic he returned to again in 2007 with a short booklet entitled
Roman Silbury and the Harvest Goddess in which he discussed the interpretation of the discovery of a Roman settlement at the side of Silbury as evidence for Romano-British pilgrimage, following in the footsteps of their prehistoric ancestors, to worship at the massive mound. The Romans often merged their deities with native counterparts and Dames argued that these Romano-British pilgrims to Silbury would therefore have been familiar with Ceres, the Roman goddess of agriculture. In his discussion Dames highlights provocative parallels between Ceres and Silbury as a Neolithic harvest Goddess with the Classical cyclic myth of Ceres fitting well with the seasonal aspects of the Silbury Goddess as revealed in his earlier book
The Avebury Cycle, arguing that the Romans recognised the annual renewal of Silbury and the Avebury monuments as evidence that the Silbury Goddess may have been worshipped at the start of each prehistoric harvest cycle from 2500 BC onwards.
Questioning whether Romano-British offerings at the nearby Neolithic West Kennet long barrow could be associated with Ceres' annual loss of her daughter, Proserpina, to the winter Underworld, Dames suggests that only 350 yards from Silbury is the Swallowhead spring, the birthplace of the River Kennet, and that such a site would be ideal for revering the Roman Tellus Mater or
'Mother Earth'.

In this latest work
Silbury: Resolving the Enigma (2010) Dames considers that the substantial new discoveries at Silbury, both inside and immediately around the monument, made since his earlier works on the subject, support his hypothesis that the gigantic effigy of the Silbury Goddess as a divine
'Lady of the Lake' squatting on her right side in the act of giving birth. He states that we share with our ancestors essentially the same bodies and brains within the same terrestrial, subterranean and celestial realms which underlies the sense of continuity of his argument.
He opens the book with a discussion of the state of the monument that still persists through the passage of time after surviving the hostile efforts of the Christian Church in its attempt to eradicate pre-Christian religion forms of worship at pagan temples inherited from our Neolithic forebears which destroyed so much of the Avebury complex. However, excavations of the last few hundred years by archaeologists and treasure seekers have ultimately led to the monument becoming unstable with the emergence of a large hole appearing on the summit in 2000. By 2008 this crater was 8 metres across and some 15 metres deep. The collapse is thought to have been caused by the shaft dug by the Duke of Northumberland and Colonel Drax in 1776, which was almost certainly not filled in properly after the excavation was completed. But still Silbury survives despite these later day desecrations.
Dames recaps and brings up to date his earlier works on the Silbury Goddess including the relevance of the Swallowhead spring before going in depth about Silbury's Roman town and Roman August at the site of the mound, emphasising that the Romans merged their own corn goddess,
Ceres, with the Neolithic deity of Silbury. Dames recounts how the Neolithic pregnant Mother Goddess, in superhuman form, could turn into a Sacred Pig, which he suggests probably follows an early Neolithic tradition found widely across Europe where the Mother Goddess is often depicted as a white sow. In addition, the Romans brought with them to Silbury traces of a Neolithic sow-venerating tradition. At the end of the harvest a sow was sacrificed to
Ceres, while at Roman funerals a sow was offered to her daughter
Prosperine, the ancient Roman goddess whose story is the basis of a myth of Springtime. Similarly, in a ritual offering in ancient Greece, young pigs were thrown in to the abyss which were said to be the goddess in her form as
Persephone, daughter of Demeter and Zeus and Queen of the Underworld; the descent and return of the goddess bringing about the change of seasons.
Although Silbury is certainly unique, Dames argues that people were drawn to evocative features in the natural landscape and as such isolated hills were seen to embody the same procreative theme of the pregnant mound, being artificially 'modified' to enhance its suitability for 'First Fruits' ritual performances. He includes a survey of Britain's
'Mother mountains', such as
Mam Tor in Derbyshire, to which folklore from Celtic and English traditions of pagan worship to the Silbury prototype has adhered.
Dames views are not popular with all, least of all Archaeologists
[2] who cannot see beyond the surface of Silbury and whose excavations over the centuries have been obsessed with digging
into the hill. Since the publication of the
The Silbury Treasure in 1976 most archaeologists have ignored or dismissed Dames interpretation of the mound, yet for all the tons of chalk rubble they have turned over they fail to offer a credible alternative and seem incapable of grasping the spirituality of the Neolithic by persistently placing 21st Century values and perceptions in the minds of the mound builders.
Perhaps Dames is correct in his hypothesis that we shouldn't be looking
inside Silbury but in the wider context of the relationship with the surrounding environment; evidently Neolithic religion, the
Language of the Goddess, was a spirituality man shared with the landscape; they were one - a situation we cannot hope to fully understand in our plastic hi-tech modern world.
Table of Contents:
1. Excavators' Tales
2. Earthing the Monument
3.Silbury and Swallowhead
4. Central Ideas
5. Silbury's Roman Town
6. Cuda, Matres, Sil
7. Silbury's Roman August
8. Transfigurations
9. A Bevy of Silburies
10. The Vanishing Effigy
11. The Plough-Jags and Durga
Postscript: The Drax Letters
Notes
Bibliography
Sources of Illustrations
Index
Index of Illustrations
*
Notes:
1.
Footsteps of the Goddess in Britain and Ireland – Michael Dames
2. Review by Jim Leary in
British Archaeology Issue 114, September/October 2010 who states: “
Throughout Dames portrays archaeologists as feckless academics, over-reliant on science and closed to the outside world”, adding that the book is
“full of factual errors”.
Jim Leary was Fieldwork Director of the
Silbury Hill Conservation Project for English Heritage, and is co-author with David Field of
The Story of Silbury Hill, which sets out to tell the archaeological story of the mound, due to be published by English Heritage on 1st October 2010.
Michael Dames books:
Roman Silbury and the Harvest Goddess – 2007, Heart of Albion Press
Taliesin's Travels:
A Demi-god at Large – 2005, Heart of Albion Press
Merlin and Wales:
A Magician's Landscape – 2002, Thames & Hudson
Mythic Ireland – 1992, Thames & Hudson
The Avebury Cycle – 1977, Thames & Hudson
The Silbury Treasure:
The Great Goddess Rediscovered – 1976, Thames & Hudson
* * *